More Information

Discover Houses for Rent in Middletown, NY

Found outside of Newburgh, this city in the Hudson Valley is situated near the Wallkill River and the base of the Shawangunk Mountains. Homes for rent in Middletown benefit from the community's proximity to Poughkeepsie and other fun New York locales.

Interesting Facts About Middletown for New Residents

  • John Green first purchased land in Middletown and probably settled the area around 1744. It earned its name because of its central location between pre-existing communities in the region.
  • The First Congregational Church of Middletown was established in 1785 and has the tallest spire in the city. The building that stands today was built in 1872.
  • The city grew along with the Erie Railroad and the New York, Ontario and Western Railway. During the 1970s, many New York City police officers, firefighters and other union workers moved to the area.

Useful Resources for New Middletown Renters

  • Middletown is home to the Kiwanis Club, an organization that has been serving the surrounding area since 1922. These volunteers help shelter the homeless, feed the hungry, build playgrounds and raise funds for pediatric research.
  • The Middletown Thrall Library has been providing the community with enriching educational resources for more than 100 years. First opened in 1901, its wide collection of materials spans both print and electronic formats. 
  • The Historic Paramount Theatre has been open to Middletown residents since 1930, offering a range of acts including movies, stand up comedy and live bands. It seats more than 1,000 people and is one of the cornerstones of the city's downtown area.

What to Do in Middletown

Living in the city of Middletown allows families to enjoy the burgeoning downtown area that's rich with entertainment and brings citizens together to build a strong community.

Sort By:

  • Verizon FiOS
Northwoods

Northwoods

Middletown, NY 10940 (0.74 miles)

Price: From $1,350

(845) 476-3088

Beds: 1 - 2, Baths: 1 - 2

Current Rent Specials
Sterling Parc at Middletown

Sterling Parc at Middletown

Middletown, NY 10940 (0.86 miles)

Price: From $1,350

(845) 271-1450

Beds: 1 - 2, Baths: 1 - 2

Current Rent Specials
Sutton Hill Apartments

Sutton Hill Apartments

Middletown, NY 10940 (1.48 miles)

Price: $965-$1,755

(845) 256-8376

Beds: 1 - 3, Baths: 1 - 2

Current Rent Specials
Stevens Manor Apartments

Stevens Manor Apartments

Middletown, NY 10941 (3.20 miles)

Price: $775-$1,225

(845) 440-1918

Beds: Studio - 2, Baths: 1

Current Rent Specials
Country Manor Apartments

Country Manor Apartments

Middletown, NY 10940 (1.73 miles)

Price: From $910

(845) 520-9721

Beds: 1 - 2, Baths: 1½

Current Rent Specials
The Brewery

The Brewery

Middletown, NY 10940 (0.77 miles)

Price: From $803

(845) 256-8117

Beds: Studio - 2, Baths: 1

Current Rent Specials
Horizons at Wawayanda

Horizons at Wawayanda

Middletown, NY 10940 (1.85 miles)

Price: $906-$1,238

(845) 765-3248

Beds: 1 - 3, Baths: 1

Current Rent Specials
Tall Oaks Apartments

Tall Oaks Apartments

Middletown, NY 10940 (1.03 miles)

Price: $787-$1,091

(845) 520-9718

Beds: 1 - 3, Baths: 1

Current Rent Specials
Rockwood Gardens

Rockwood Gardens

Middletown, NY 10941 (3.22 miles)

Price: $905-$1,205

(845) 271-1447

Beds: 1 - 2, Baths: 1

Current Rent Specials
Senior Horizons at Silver Lake

Senior Horizons at Silver Lake

Middletown, NY 10940 (2.24 miles)

Price: $799-$927

(845) 476-3086

Beds: 1 - 2, Baths: 1

Current Rent Specials
Beautiful Historic Home in cozy neighborhood

Beautiful Historic Home in cozy neighborhood

Franklin, NJ 07416 (24.04 miles) (#1593759)

Price: $1,400

(866) 479-4877

Beds: 3, Baths: 1

Current Rent Specials
Furnished Studio - Fishkill

Furnished Studio - Fishkill

Fishkill, NY 12524 (27.72 miles)

Price: From $1,470

(845) 520-9731

Beds: 1, Baths: 1

Current Rent Specials
Furnished Studio - Fishkill

Furnished Studio - Fishkill

Fishkill, NY 12524 (28.11 miles)

Price: From $1,575

(845) 476-3197

Beds: 1, Baths: 1

Current Rent Specials
Charming 2 Bed 1 Bath

Charming 2 Bed 1 Bath

Peekskill, NY 10566 (28.20 miles) (#1605378)

Price: $1,200

(877) 542-0122

Beds: 2, Baths: 1

Current Rent Specials
Classic Cornwall

Classic Cornwall

Cornwall, NY 12518 (20.14 miles) (#1367381)

Price: $1,100

(877) 885-7436

Beds: 2, Baths: 1

Current Rent Specials
Great 2 bedroom house for Rent

Great 2 bedroom house for Rent

Walden, NY 12527 (16.66 miles) (#1605758)

Price: $1,500

(855) 263-4736

Beds: 2, Baths: 2

Current Rent Specials
Carriage Hill Apartments & Woodhill Fletcher

Carriage Hill Apartments & Woodhill Fletcher

Goshen, NY 10924 (5.14 miles)

Price: From $1,115

(845) 610-6009

Beds: 1 - 2, Baths: 1

Current Rent Specials
Vineyard Commons 55+ Active Adult Community

Vineyard Commons 55+ Active Adult Community

Highland, NY 12528 (28.77 miles)

Price: $1,685-$2,100

(845) 232-2296

Beds: 2 - 3, Baths: 2

Current Rent Specials

Results per Page:

All information provided by the listing manager is deemed reliable but is not guaranteed and should be independently verified.

Additional Resources

DCMS replaced content for: /new-york/middletown/ (via catch-all: city_pages)