83 Houses For Rent in Setauket, NY

Sort: Best Match

No results were found.

Start another search or adjust your filter settings above.
121-150 of 83 properties

Page 5 of 3

  1. Home
  2. New York
  3. Setauket

Nearby Zip Codes

Overview of Setauket, New York

Located on the North Shore of Long Island in Suffolk County, Setauket, New York is a charming hamlet that carries a rich historical past. Known for its picturesque landscapes and conveniently located amenities, Setauket is often admired for its inviting suburban feel. With its blend of modern attractions and a touch of history, this hamlet is always brimming with life, making it an excellent place to consider when looking for houses for rent.

Setauket’s location makes it an appealing option for those considering renting a house in the area. The hamlet is flanked by Port Jefferson to the east and Stony Brook to the west, providing renters easy access to these vibrant neighborhoods. With Route 25A running through it, travelling within and beyond Setauket becomes hassle-free for the residents. Several parks are scattered throughout this charming community such as West Meadow Beach, Frank Melville Memorial Park and Patriots Hollow State Forest which provide great opportunities for residents to enjoy outdoor activities.

Setauket also offers an array of dining options from cozy coffee shops to fancy fine-dining restaurants along Main Street. Local businesses thrive here which provide all necessities within close proximity. For those interested in history or culture, a visit to The Setauket Neighborhood House or The Three Village Historical Society can prove intriguing. When choosing a rental house in this captivating hamlet that combines history with modern comfort, you will be stepping into an enriched cultural hub laden with amenities that provide convenience on a day-to-day basis without compromising on the charm of suburban living.

Location Highlights of Setauket, New York

Setauket, New York, offers a charming blend of history and modernity amidst lush greenery and picturesque water views. Nestled on the North Shore of Long Island, Setauket is an idyllic spot for those looking for houses for rent in an enchanting suburban setting. It is a neighborhood that boasts close proximity to stunning parks like Frank Melville Memorial Park, where families can enjoy tranquil afternoons by the pond or walks on nature trails.

This location also provides easy access to key roads such as Route 25A and Nicholls Road, ensuring convenient commutation. For dining out options, Setauket's location is stellar with a charming cluster of restaurants along Main Street offering diverse culinary experiences. Its proximity to the vibrant Stony Brook University opens up opportunities for attending cultural events or taking continuing education classes. Not to forget the Setauket Harbor and the surrounding beaches that not only offer beautiful waterfront views but also allow residents to engage in outdoor activities such as boating and fishing.

Population and Community

Setauket has a peaceful, welcoming atmosphere fostered by its harmonious community. The population comprises a blend of different age groups, creating dynamic diversity within the residential areas. This combined with its tranquil environment makes it an attractive destination for families looking for houses to rent.

The community spirit thrives in numerous local events that are held in Setauket's parks or community centers throughout the year. From local farmers' markets on Sunday mornings to festive parades during holiday seasons, there are always opportunities for residents to engage with their neighbors and feel part of this close-knit community. Its neighborhood associations and community organizations make everyone feel at home while also preserving the historical charm of the area through their efforts which brings people together creating an inviting environment making it a place many long to call home.

Things to Do and Points of Interest in Setauket, New York

Setauket, New York, located on Long Island’s North Shore, is a charming town full of history and natural beauty. One must-visit spot is the Setauket Neighborhood House. Built in the year 1720, this restored building serves as a gathering place for community events and activities. It's an excellent opportunity for those new in town or looking for houses for rent to meet locals and immerse themselves in the town's traditions and culture.

Known for its scenic beauty, outdoor enthusiasts will enjoy exploring the Frank Melville Memorial Park. The park offers beautiful ponds, walking paths lined with lush green trees, historic buildings and even a homestead museum. Nature lovers will appreciate Setauket's access to both woodland trails such as those found at Patriots Hollow State Forest and coastal routes like West Meadow Beach with its stunning seaside views.

Is Setauket, New York a Good Place to Live?

Setauket's charm goes beyond recreational activities and gorgeous landscapes; it extends into everyday living that makes it a wonderful place to call home. One of the primary factors people take into consideration when moving is connectivity and accessibility to essential amenities. Setauket has easy access to major roads such as Route 25A for convenient travel around Long Island or into New York City. It also offers various dining options along Main Street that will satisfy any palette.

Families considering making the move will appreciate the high-quality education systems within reach in Setauket. The Three Village Central School District serves this area where there are options from elementary through high school levels available. This also includes Stony Brook University just minutes away from Setauket itself.

Furthermore, if you're seeking houses for rent or looking to relocate your family permanently in this region of Long Island, you can expect a lively spirit of community with annual events like the Setauket Harbor Day bringing residents together for a fun-filled day of activities. With its rich historical roots, engaging community, excellent schools, and natural beauty, Setauket, New York has much to offer.

What It's Like Living in Setauket, New York

Setauket, New York, is a quaint and charming hamlet situated on the North Shore of Long Island. Encapsulated by scenic views of Port Jefferson Harbor and Setauket Harbor, the area boasts a wealth of natural beauty that resonates throughout each neighborhood and street. Taking a leisurely stroll down Main Street, you're greeted with historic storefronts housing unique boutiques and eateries, creating a sense of timelessness that is quintessentially Setauket.

Pinpointed near the bustling N Country Road and Route 25A, you'll find the heart of this community, Frank Melville Memorial Park. Every turn within this 24-acre park reveals tranquil ponds, grassy knolls, beautiful gardens teeming with local flora, rustic barns turned event venues and winding walking trails that beckon to be explored.

Advantages of Renting a Home in Setauket, New York

Renting a home in Setauket comes with numerous benefits that go beyond gorgeous houses for rent. The location itself is an advantage. You're in proximity to educational institutions like Stony Brook University which is just off Nicolls Road while having Setauket Elementary School nestled within the residential district serves families well.

With houses for rent dispersed around key attractions like Emma Clark Library or along beautiful roads like Dyke Road or Bennetts Road leading towards Strongs Neck area; access to cultural sources of recreation becomes an unbeatable amenity. Locations nearby Harborfront Park or overlooking West Meadow Beach provide breathtaking views right from your living room window which are typical for homes available for rent in Setauket.

Another perk when renting a home here is immersion into an involved community. Whether joining the local gardening club or participating in art classes at Gallery North located on N Country Rd., settling into this close-knit community is less intimidating when you're simply renting. Ideal for trying out this east-coast lifestyle without a long-term commitment, renting in Setauket provides an inviting avenue into experiencing the charm of a Long Island hamlet.

Median Earnings in Setauket, New York

Situated in the town of Brookhaven, Setauket is a census-designated place that boasts a comfortable lifestyle. Talking about the median earnings for its residents, the data points at an average that aligns with the overall economy. Taking into account various occupations and industries present in the area, from classic nine-to-five office jobs to self-employed entrepreneurs, the median salary reflects a balanced economy.

While many may ponder over houses for rent while considering their financial viability and location, it is important to look at median income as an economic indicator. Considering the median earnings in Setauket can provide valuable insight into how people with different employment statuses contribute to the economic fabric of this New York community.

Schools & Education in Setauket, New York

Stepping into the realm of education and schools in Setauket, there are two key schools offering comprehensive learning opportunities for young learners. These educational institutions contribute richly to shaping a well-rounded foundation for the children residing in this area.

For families considering moving to Setauket or looking at houses for rent, they might find it encouraging to know that these schools are conveniently located with easy access from most parts of town. The schools lie near North Country Road and Main Street which are two main thoroughfares of this community. In addition, nearby Frank Melville Memorial Park provides an additional outdoor space where children can balance their academic focus with recreational activities once school is done for the day. Being part of Setauket's educational landscape provides children with opportunities for growth embedded within their own neighborhood. The local schools also foster stronger community ties by bringing families together through school events and activities.

Setauket, New York is a charming community with several neighborhoods, one of these being Brookhaven. Nestled amidst breathtaking landscapes, Brookhaven offers an array of houses for rent, featuring modern amenities and unique architectural designs. Residents here enjoy idyllic surroundings with numerous parks and recreational facilities in the vicinity. Hosting a variety of restaurants, shopping outlets and local businesses, Brookhaven proves to be not only a picturesque but also a convenient place to dwell. Renting a house in this vibrant neighborhood grants you access to an engaging lifestyle amidst tranquility and convenience.

Common questions asked in Setauket, New York

🏠 Where can I find cheap rental houses in Setauket, New York?

Check out Rentals.com's cheap rental houses in Setauket. You can use our price filters to find rental houses under $2000, under $2500, under $3000, under $4000, under $5000

🏠 How big of a rental house can I afford?

Find Studio, 1 Bedroom, 2 Bedroom, 3 Bedroom, 4 Bedroom rental houses within your budget in Setauket, New York. Or you can search for houses over 600 sq.ft, 800 sq.ft, 1000 sq.ft, 1200 sq.ft, 1400 sq.ft, 1600 sq.ft.

🏠 How can I find a rental house in a specific school district?

Rentals.com was built with parents in mind. Within Setauket we have 83 rental houses spread across multiple school districts. To help narrow your search, simply enter the school name within the Rentals.com search bar to find rental homes in that school district.

Rentals.com is part of the Rent. Network of Sites
© 2024 Rent Group Inc. All photos, videos, text and other content are the property of Rent Group Inc. RENTALS.COM and the RENTALS.COM Trade Dress are registered trademarks of Rent Group Inc. All rights reserved.
If you are using a screen reader, or are having trouble reading this website, please email accessibilityfeedback@rent.com.
Equal Housing Opportunity
Showing 0 of 83