58 Houses For Rent in Shelter Island, NY
Sort: Best Match
$90,000
6bd 4.5ba 4,600 sq. ft.
$40,000
3bd 1ba 1,056 sq. ft.
Loading...
$3,800
2bd 2.5ba 1,100 sq. ft.
$4,800
2bd 2.5ba 1,800 sq. ft.
$22,000
4bd 2.5ba 1,784 sq. ft.
$70,000
3bd 2ba
$35,000
4bd 3.5ba 3,000 sq. ft.
$10,000
2bd 1ba
$14,000
4bd 3ba 2,300 sq. ft.
Loading...
$75,000
3bd 3ba
$35,000
3bd 3ba 2,846 sq. ft.
$50,000
8bd 7ba 5,400 sq. ft.
$23,500
4bd 2ba
$40,000
4bd 2ba
$21,500
4bd 2ba 2,400 sq. ft.
$23,000
4bd 3.5ba 3,800 sq. ft.
Loading...
$20,000
4bd 3.5ba 1,888 sq. ft.
$10,500
2bd 2ba 1,400 sq. ft.
$175,000
5bd 4.5ba 3,300 sq. ft.
$25,000
4bd 2.5ba 3,200 sq. ft.
$45,000
3bd 3.5ba 2,100 sq. ft.
$320,000
5bd 3ba
$12,000
3bd 1ba
$12,500
2bd 2ba
$25,000
5bd 5ba 7,000 sq. ft.
$9,000
8bd 7.5ba 8,500 sq. ft.
$70,000
4bd 3.5ba 2,300 sq. ft.
$30,000
4bd 2ba 2,400 sq. ft.
$25,000
4bd 3ba 1,328 sq. ft.
$55,000
4bd 2ba 1,520 sq. ft.
Number of Bedrooms
Shelter Island House Options
Shelter Island
Houses 3D and Video ToursShelter Island
Houses with Air ConditioningShelter Island
Houses with DishwasherShelter Island
Houses with Fire PlaceShelter Island
Houses with Patio / BalconyShelter Island
Houses with Washer / Dryer In UnitPet Friendly Houses for Rent in Shelter IslandCheap Houses for Rent in Shelter IslandLuxury Houses for Rent in Shelter Island
Nearby Cities
Looking for more?
Other Properties in New York
145 Attorney St unit 1125 E State St45 Wall St unit 1209St John Towers Apartments416 E 13th St unit 4EAlexander EstatesCrest Manor ApartmentsVillas Of BrightonTimberlane Estates120-56 168th St54 4th Ave #3Parkview Apartments & Townhomes931 Brayton Park Pl unit 1st150 4th Ave unit 11G151 Tompkins St unit 2Edgewater Apartment Homes34 S Front StWestminster Place Apartments21 Stuyvesant Oval unit 12-E200 Water St unit 81658-1/2 Inslee St unit 1391 Flower City Park106 Old Stone Hill Rd2065 Morris AveParkside Village455 W 37th St unit 717Chili Commons Apartments95 Wall St unit 01-1615The Knick ApartmentsFoxrun Apartments
Common questions asked in Shelter Island, New York
🏠 Where can I find cheap rental houses in Shelter Island, New York?
Check out Rentals.com's cheap rental houses in Shelter Island. You can use our price filters to find rental houses under $4000, under $5000
🏠 How big of a rental house can I afford?
Find Studio, 1 Bedroom, 2 Bedroom, 3 Bedroom, 4 Bedroom rental houses within your budget in Shelter Island, New York. Or you can search for houses over 1200 sq.ft, 1400 sq.ft, 1600 sq.ft, 1800 sq.ft, 2000 sq.ft, 2400 sq.ft.
🏠 How can I find a rental house in a specific school district?
Rentals.com was built with parents in mind. Within Shelter Island we have 58 rental houses spread across multiple school districts. To help narrow your search, simply enter the school name within the Rentals.com search bar to find rental homes in that school district.
Rentals.com is part of the Rent. Network of Sites
© 2024 Rent Group Inc. All photos, videos, text and other content are the property of Rent Group Inc. RENTALS.COM and the RENTALS.COM Trade Dress are registered trademarks of Rent Group Inc. All rights reserved.
If you are using a screen reader, or are having trouble reading this website, please email accessibilityfeedback@rent.com.