Houses for Rent in Shelter Island, New York

Rentals Available: 51

Sort By:

    Spotlight Property

    Greybarn Amityville

    Amityville, NY 11701

    Price: From $2,925

    Beds: 1 - 2, Baths: 1 - 2

    (631) 412-8036

    Heron Ln And Sandpiper Rd

    $12,000

    4 Beds / 4 baths

    Shelter Island, NY 11964
    (631) 749-0500

    Grand Ave And Summerfield Pl

    $2,000

    5 Beds / 3 baths

    Shelter Island, NY 11964
    (631) 749-0500

    Waverly Pl And Spring Garden Ave

    $11,000

    3 Beds / 2 baths

    Shelter Island, NY 11964
    (631) 749-0500

    Tims Trail And Old Buck Run

    $8,000

    5 Beds / 3 baths

    Shelter Island, NY 11964
    (631) 749-0500

    Ny 114 And N Ferry Rd

    $7,500

    3 Beds / 1 baths

    Shelter Island, NY 11964
    (631) 749-0500

    Marina Point Drive

    Please Call

    2 Beds / 2 baths

    Old Saybrook, CT 06475
    (855) 378-2214

    Country Glen

    $1,175-$1,745

    1 - 3 Beds / 1 - 2 baths

    Groton, CT 06340
    (860) 357-6087

    The Villages At Shore Landing

    $725-$1,585

    Studio - 2 Beds / 1 baths

    New London, CT 06320
    (860) 254-7467

    Post & Main

    Please Call

    1 - 2 Beds / 1 - 2 baths

    Old Saybrook, CT 06475
    (203) 712-0394

    Town and Country Apartments

    $1,419-$1,629

    Studio - 1 Bed / 1 baths

    Hampton Bays, NY 11946
    (631) 830-6711

    Marshfield Apartments

    $875-$1,195

    1 - 2 Beds / 1 baths

    North Branford, CT 06471
    (203) 318-4597

    Nutmeg Woods

    $799-$1,480

    Studio - 3 Beds / 1 baths

    New London, CT 06320
    (860) 254-7468

    Villas at Pine Hills

    From $1,544

    Studio - 2 Beds / 1 baths

    Manorville, NY 11949
    (631) 721-9057

    La Triumphe

    $1,050-$1,850

    1 - 3 Beds / 1 - 2 baths

    Groton, CT 06340
    (860) 357-6080

    The Sound at Gateway Commons

    $1,390-$2,175

    Studio - 3 Beds / 1 - 2 baths

    East Lyme, CT 06333
    (860) 333-6045

    The Ledges Apartments

    From $1,150

    1 - 3 Beds / 1 - 3 baths

    Groton, CT 06340
    (860) 288-8895

    Groton Townhouses

    $975-$1,575

    1 - 3 Beds / 1 baths

    Groton, CT 06340
    (860) 373-2186

    Peppertree Apartments

    $719-$1,100

    Studio - 2 Beds / 1 baths

    Groton, CT 06340
    (860) 733-4199

    Village Apartments

    From $1,099

    2 - 3 Beds / 2 baths

    Uncasville, CT 06382
    (860) 910-4475

    Montoya

    $1,299-$1,800

    1 - 2 Beds / 1 - 2 baths

    Branford, CT 06405
    (203) 937-2358

    Omega Estates

    $895-$1,395

    1 - 3 Beds / 1 baths

    Branford, CT 06405
    (844) 787-9790

    Gull Harbor

    $750-$850

    1 Bed / 1 baths

    New London, CT 06320
    (860) 288-8826

    Crocker House

    From $725

    Studio - 2 Beds / 1 baths

    New London, CT 06320
    (860) 319-0135

    Fairfield Pines East

    $1,530-$2,025

    Studio - 2 Beds / 1 - 2 baths

    Flanders, NY 11901
    (631) 830-0043

    Long Meadow Landings

    $975-$1,385

    2 Beds / 1 baths

    Groton, CT 06340
    (860) 357-6081

    Fieldside Apartments

    From $845

    1 - 2 Beds / 1 baths

    Groton, CT 06340
    (860) 910-0457

    Faire Harbour Landings

    $950-$1,450

    1 - 3 Beds / 1 baths

    New London, CT 06320
    (860) 272-4766

    Phoenix Apartments

    $950  

    1 Bed / 1 baths

    Groton, CT 06340
    (860) 691-9175

    Village View Apartments

    From $850

    1 - 2 Beds / 1 baths

    Deep River, CT 06417
    (203) 764-2302

    Groton Estates

    $860-$1,315

    1 - 3 Beds / 1 baths

    Groton, CT 06340
    (860) 288-8863

    All information provided by the listing manager is deemed reliable but is not guaranteed and should be independently verified.