111 Middle Island, NY Houses Under $5,000
Sort: Best Match
Pet Friendly
Furnished
$3,115+
Fairfield Knolls North At Port Jefferson Apartments
Details
2
2 Bed
$3,795
1299+ sq. ft.
2
2 Bed
$3,645
1299+ sq. ft.
2
2 Bed
$3,950
1315+ sq. ft.
2
2 Bed
$3,620
1315+ sq. ft.
2
2 Bed
$3,900
1340+ sq. ft.
2
2 Bed
$3,645
1340+ sq. ft.
2
2 Bed
$3,300
1376+ sq. ft.
2
2 Bed
$3,945
1381+ sq. ft.
2
2 Bed
$3,745
1381+ sq. ft.
2
2 Bed
$3,945
1446+ sq. ft.
2
2 Bed
$3,765
1446+ sq. ft.
2
2 Bed
$3,860
1466+ sq. ft.
2
2 Bed
$3,760
1466+ sq. ft.
2
2 Bed
$3,465
1466+ sq. ft.
2
2 Bed
$3,455
1466+ sq. ft.
2
2 Bed
$3,455
1479+ sq. ft.
2
2 Bed
$3,920
1481+ sq. ft.
2
2 Bed
$3,565
1481+ sq. ft.
2
2 Bed
$3,120
1511+ sq. ft.
2
2 Bed
$3,115
1511+ sq. ft.
2
2 Bed
$4,005
1597+ sq. ft.
2
2 Bed
$3,780
1597+ sq. ft.
2
2 Bed
$4,050
1597+ sq. ft.
2
2 Bed
$3,450
1656+ sq. ft.
2
2 Bed
$3,240
1750+ sq. ft.
2
2 Bed
$3,215
1750+ sq. ft.
2
2 Bed
$3,280
1750+ sq. ft.
2
2 Bed
$3,295
1750+ sq. ft.
2
2 Bed
$4,000
1958+ sq. ft.
2
2 Bed
$3,700
1958+ sq. ft.
PetsDogs/Cats
Lease TermsLease term: 12 month or 24 month leases.
NeighborhoodBrookhaven
View All Details
10+ Units Available
Pet Friendly
$2,350+
Renaissance Bay Apartments
Details
1
1 Bed
$2,350
620+ sq. ft.
2
2 Bed
$2,575
800+ sq. ft.
1
1 Bed
$2,450
830+ sq. ft.
1
1 Bed
$2,775
900+ sq. ft.
2
2 Bed
$2,895
954+ sq. ft.
2
2 Bed
$2,995
1050+ sq. ft.
2
2 Bed
$2,995
1060+ sq. ft.
PetsDogs/Cats
Lease Terms12-Month
NeighborhoodBrookhaven
View All Details
4 Units Available
Loading...
Pet Friendly
$3,710+
Fairfield Gables At South Setauket Apartments
Details
1
1 Bed
$3,710
1145+ sq. ft.
1
1 Bed
$3,830
1145+ sq. ft.
2
2 Bed
$4,120
1290+ sq. ft.
2
2 Bed
$4,105
1290+ sq. ft.
2
2 Bed
$4,145
1315+ sq. ft.
1
1 Bed
$3,980
1340+ sq. ft.
3
3 Bed
$4,215
1360+ sq. ft.
3
3 Bed
$4,270
1360+ sq. ft.
PetsDogs/Cats
Lease Terms12 & 24 month lease terms.
NeighborhoodBrookhaven
View All Details
8 Units Available
Pet Friendly
$3,070+
Fairfield At Ronkonkoma Apartments
Details
3
3 Bed
$3,790
999+ sq. ft.
2
2 Bed
$3,070
1153+ sq. ft.
2
2 Bed
$3,115
1166+ sq. ft.
2
2 Bed
$3,090
1179+ sq. ft.
2
2 Bed
$3,220
1185+ sq. ft.
2
2 Bed
$3,190
1193+ sq. ft.
2
2 Bed
$3,400
1193+ sq. ft.
3
3 Bed
$3,780
1613+ sq. ft.
3
3 Bed
$3,885
1618+ sq. ft.
PetsDogs/Cats
Lease Terms12 & 24 month lease terms.
NeighborhoodBrookhaven
View All Details
9 Units Available
$2,085+
Fairfield At East Patchogue Apartments
Details
1
1 Bed
$2,340
999+ sq. ft.
2
2 Bed
$2,835
999+ sq. ft.
2
2 Bed
$2,810
999+ sq. ft.
1
1 Bed
$2,310
999+ sq. ft.
1
1 Bed
$2,095
999+ sq. ft.
1
1 Bed
$2,085
999+ sq. ft.
Lease Terms12-Month, 24-Month
NeighborhoodBrookhaven
View All Details
6 Units Available
Pet Friendly
$2,109+
Brookwood At Holbrook Apartments
Details
1
1 Bed
$2,109
650+ sq. ft.
2
2 Bed
$2,614
870+ sq. ft.
PetsDogs/Cats
Lease Terms12-Month
NeighborhoodIslip
View All Details
2 Units Available
Pet Friendly
$2,000+
Fairfield At Port Jefferson Apartments
Details
S
Studio
$2,000
480+ sq. ft.
1
1 Bed
$2,145
495+ sq. ft.
1
1 Bed
$2,435
505+ sq. ft.
1
1 Bed
$2,435
560+ sq. ft.
1
1 Bed
$2,435
560+ sq. ft.
1
1 Bed
$2,435
605+ sq. ft.
2
2 Bed
$2,905
690+ sq. ft.
2
2 Bed
$2,905
740+ sq. ft.
2
2 Bed
$2,905
740+ sq. ft.
3
3 Bed
$3,370
1168+ sq. ft.
PetsCats
Lease Terms12 & 24 month lease terms.
NeighborhoodBrookhaven
View All Details
Pet Friendly
$2,320+
Fairfield North At Patchogue Apartments
Details
1
1 Bed
$2,320
850+ sq. ft.
1
1 Bed
$2,320
850+ sq. ft.
2
2 Bed
$2,815
995+ sq. ft.
2
2 Bed
$2,815
995+ sq. ft.
PetsDogs/Cats
Lease Terms12 & 24 month lease terms.
NeighborhoodBrookhaven
View All Details
4 Units Available
Pet Friendly
$3,095+
Fairfield Landmark At Port Jefferson Village Apartments
Details
1
1 Bed
$3,095
790+ sq. ft.
1
1 Bed
$3,095
790+ sq. ft.
2
2 Bed
$3,580
820+ sq. ft.
2
2 Bed
$3,320
850+ sq. ft.
2
2 Bed
$3,420
900+ sq. ft.
1
1 Bed
$3,150
930+ sq. ft.
2
2 Bed
$3,600
970+ sq. ft.
2
2 Bed
$3,710
1000+ sq. ft.
2
2 Bed
$3,720
1030+ sq. ft.
PetsDogs/Cats
Lease Terms12 & 24 month lease terms.
NeighborhoodBrookhaven
View All Details
9 Units Available
Loading...
$2,125+
Fairfield Westlake At Patchogue Apartments
Details
2
2 Bed
$2,640
1
1 Bed
$2,125
790-791+ sq. ft.
PetsDogs/Cats
Lease Terms12 & 24 month lease terms.
NeighborhoodBrookhaven
View All Details
$2,640+
Fairfield Knolls East Apartments
Details
2
2 Bed
$2,940
999+ sq. ft.
2
2 Bed
$2,735
1346+ sq. ft.
2
2 Bed
$2,735
1346+ sq. ft.
2
2 Bed
$2,795
1401+ sq. ft.
2
2 Bed
$2,640
1479+ sq. ft.
2
2 Bed
$2,785
1480+ sq. ft.
2
2 Bed
$2,765
1496+ sq. ft.
2
2 Bed
$2,915
1615+ sq. ft.
2
2 Bed
$2,865
1759+ sq. ft.
2
2 Bed
$3,015
1826+ sq. ft.
2
2 Bed
$2,865
1963+ sq. ft.
PetsDogs/Cats
Lease Terms12 & 24 month lease terms.
NeighborhoodBrookhaven
View All Details
10+ Units Available
Pet Friendly
$2,160+
Fairfield At Lake Grove Apartments
Details
1
1 Bed
$2,330
460+ sq. ft.
S
Studio
$2,160
462+ sq. ft.
S
Studio
$2,170
462+ sq. ft.
1
1 Bed
$2,400
672+ sq. ft.
1
1 Bed
$2,400
672+ sq. ft.
2
2 Bed
$2,915
952+ sq. ft.
1
1 Bed
$2,400
999+ sq. ft.
PetsDogs
Lease Terms12, 24 month lease terms.
NeighborhoodBrookhaven
View All Details
7 Units Available
Pet Friendly
$2,435+
Fairfield Falls Apartments
Details
1
1 Bed
$2,435
650+ sq. ft.
1
1 Bed
$2,435
657+ sq. ft.
2
2 Bed
$2,895
790+ sq. ft.
2
2 Bed
$2,895
790+ sq. ft.
PetsDogs/Cats
Lease TermsVariable, 12-Month, 24-Month
NeighborhoodBrookhaven
View All Details
4 Units Available
Pet Friendly
$2,215+
Fairfield Gardens At Centereach Apartments
Details
1
1 Bed
$2,215
645+ sq. ft.
1
1 Bed
$2,215
650+ sq. ft.
1
1 Bed
$2,285
680+ sq. ft.
1
1 Bed
$2,285
685+ sq. ft.
2
2 Bed
$2,655
715+ sq. ft.
2
2 Bed
$2,655
720+ sq. ft.
PetsDogs/Cats
Lease Terms12 & 24 month lease terms.
NeighborhoodBrookhaven
View All Details
6 Units Available
Pet Friendly
$2,055+
Fairfield Lakeside At Moriches Apartments
Details
1
1 Bed
$2,190
710+ sq. ft.
1
1 Bed
$2,055
710+ sq. ft.
2
2 Bed
$2,465
800+ sq. ft.
PetsDogs/Cats
Lease Terms12, 24 month lease terms.
NeighborhoodBrookhaven
View All Details
Pet Friendly
$2,150+
Fairfield Gardens At Port Jefferson Apartments
Details
1
1 Bed
$2,150
851+ sq. ft.
1
1 Bed
$2,150
851+ sq. ft.
1
1 Bed
$2,365
939+ sq. ft.
2
2 Bed
$2,785
939+ sq. ft.
1
1 Bed
$2,365
939+ sq. ft.
2
2 Bed
$2,785
939+ sq. ft.
2
2 Bed
$2,905
1268+ sq. ft.
2
2 Bed
$2,905
1268+ sq. ft.
PetsDogs/Cats
Lease Terms12 & 24 month lease terms.
NeighborhoodBrookhaven
View All Details
8 Units Available
Loading...
$2,405+
Fairfield Hillside At Coram Apartments
Details
1
1 Bed
$2,405
800+ sq. ft.
1
1 Bed
$2,415
815+ sq. ft.
2
2 Bed
$2,630
982+ sq. ft.
2
2 Bed
$2,620
999+ sq. ft.
2
2 Bed
$3,100
999+ sq. ft.
Lease Terms12 & 24 month lease terms.
NeighborhoodBrookhaven
View All Details
5 Units Available
$3,700
The Villas At Setauket Apartments
1 Unit Available
$4,600
4bd 2.5ba 2,000 sq. ft.
$2,750
2bd 1ba 900 sq. ft.
$2,450
1bd 1ba
$4,700
4bd 3ba 2,200 sq. ft.
$2,900
2bd 1.5ba
$4,500
3bd 2.5ba
$3,750
2bd 2ba
$4,583
1bd 1ba
$4,500
5bd 3ba
$3,290
3bd 1ba 660 sq. ft.
$2,226
1bd 1ba
$3,600
3bd 1ba 1,031 sq. ft.
Number of Bedrooms
Middle Island House Options
Middle Island
Houses 3D and Video ToursMiddle Island
Houses with Air ConditioningMiddle Island
Houses with Disability AccessMiddle Island
Houses with DishwasherMiddle Island
Houses with ElevatorMiddle Island
Houses with Fire PlaceMiddle Island
Houses with GarageMiddle Island
Houses with Gated AccessMiddle Island
Houses with Patio / BalconyMiddle Island
Houses with Washer / Dryer In UnitPet Friendly Houses for Rent in Middle IslandCheap Houses for Rent in Middle IslandLuxury Houses for Rent in Middle IslandRooms for Rent in Middle Island
Nearby Cities
Port Jefferson Station, NYPatchogue, NYCoram, NYBellport, NYMiddle Island, NYPort Jefferson, NYCentereach, NYRidge, NYShirley, NYWading River, NYFarmingville, NYLake Grove, NYMastic, NYMastic Beach, NYMedford, NYSelden, NYStony Brook, NYHolbrook, NYHoltsville, NYRocky Point, NYSound Beach, NYCenter Moriches, NYEast Patchogue, NYMount Sinai, NY
Nearby Neighborhoods
Looking for more?
Other Properties in New York
Linwood Senior Living Apartments196 Freeman St unit 2CNew Paltz Gardens Apartments13 Inwood Pl #2315 Wilmot Rd150 Lenox RdAshfield Apartments19 Woodland WayWestminster Place ApartmentsBlue Heron Trail IIFairfield Oaks ApartmentsCazenovia Village/ Emerald Court Apartments215 E 164th St unit 6X55 Oxford RdCarlton Hollow Senior Apartments629 E 5th St unit 1833-30 48th Avenue313 E 81st St unit 1FE3303 Avenue N189 Cumberland St unit 189Greenway Place Apartments1 Patricia Ln230 Bryant Ave43 Bronx River Rd #4H1943 Bennett Rd65 Ludlow St unit 144 Bayview AveMosaic VillageIST2 R Apartments541 W 150th St unit 15
Rentals.com is part of the Rent. Network of Sites
© 2024 Rent Group Inc. All photos, videos, text and other content are the property of Rent Group Inc. RENTALS.COM and the RENTALS.COM Trade Dress are registered trademarks of Rent Group Inc. All rights reserved.
If you are using a screen reader, or are having trouble reading this website, please email accessibilityfeedback@rent.com.