44 Middle Island, NY Houses Under $2,500
Sort: Best Match
Pet Friendly
$2,305+
Fairfield Village At Middle Island Apartments
Details
1
1 Bed
$2,355
695+ sq. ft.
1
1 Bed
$2,325
695+ sq. ft.
1
1 Bed
$2,375
695+ sq. ft.
1
1 Bed
$2,355
740+ sq. ft.
2
2 Bed
$2,435
750+ sq. ft.
2
2 Bed
$2,415
750+ sq. ft.
1
1 Bed
$2,305
770+ sq. ft.
2
2 Bed
$2,455
785+ sq. ft.
2
2 Bed
$2,435
785+ sq. ft.
1
1 Bed
$2,335
820+ sq. ft.
PetsDogs/Cats
Lease Terms12 & 24 month lease terms.
NeighborhoodBrookhaven
View All Details
Pet Friendly
$2,340+
Fairfield Courtyard At Middle Island Apartments
Details
1
1 Bed
$2,640
999+ sq. ft.
2
2 Bed
$2,760
999+ sq. ft.
1
1 Bed
$2,615
999+ sq. ft.
1
1 Bed
$2,340
999+ sq. ft.
1
1 Bed
$2,360
999+ sq. ft.
2
2 Bed
$2,780
999+ sq. ft.
PetsDogs/Cats
Lease Terms12 & 24 month lease terms.
NeighborhoodBrookhaven
View All Details
6 Units Available
Loading...
$2,250
1bd 1ba
Pet Friendly
$1,864+
Brookwood At Ridge Apartments
Details
1
1 Bed
$1,864
636+ sq. ft.
1
1 Bed
$1,999
636+ sq. ft.
PetsDogs/Cats
Lease Terms12-Month
NeighborhoodBrookhaven
View All Details
2 Units Available
Pet Friendly
$1,950+
Fairfield Courtyard At Coram Apartments
Details
S
Studio
$1,990
470+ sq. ft.
S
Studio
$1,950
470+ sq. ft.
1
1 Bed
$2,225
693+ sq. ft.
1
1 Bed
$2,295
765+ sq. ft.
1
1 Bed
$2,230
783+ sq. ft.
2
2 Bed
$2,655
825+ sq. ft.
2
2 Bed
$2,755
825+ sq. ft.
1
1 Bed
$2,325
830+ sq. ft.
2
2 Bed
$2,685
855+ sq. ft.
2
2 Bed
$2,795
980+ sq. ft.
PetsDogs/Cats
Lease Terms12, 18, 24 month leases.
NeighborhoodBrookhaven
View All Details
Pet Friendly
$2,500+
Fairfield Charles Pond At Coram Apartments
Details
1
1 Bed
$2,500
723+ sq. ft.
1
1 Bed
$2,550
760+ sq. ft.
1
1 Bed
891+ sq. ft.
1
1 Bed
$2,810
907+ sq. ft.
1
1 Bed
$2,745
913+ sq. ft.
1
1 Bed
$2,770
924+ sq. ft.
1
1 Bed
$2,995
1058+ sq. ft.
1
1 Bed
$2,995
1060+ sq. ft.
2
2 Bed
$3,115
1102+ sq. ft.
2
2 Bed
$3,190
1198+ sq. ft.
2
2 Bed
$3,295
1257+ sq. ft.
2
2 Bed
1399+ sq. ft.
PetsDogs/Cats
Lease Terms12-Month, 24-Month
NeighborhoodBrookhaven
View All Details
10+ Units Available
Pet Friendly
$2,330+
Fairfield Village At Coram Apartments
Details
2
2 Bed
$2,840
999+ sq. ft.
1
1 Bed
$2,330
999+ sq. ft.
1
1 Bed
$2,350
999+ sq. ft.
2
2 Bed
$2,890
999+ sq. ft.
PetsDogs/Cats
Lease Terms12 & 24 month lease terms.
NeighborhoodBrookhaven
View All Details
4 Units Available
Pet Friendly
$2,475+
Fairfield Townhouses At Holtsville Apartments
Details
2
2 Bed
$2,925
2
2 Bed
$3,050
2
2 Bed
$3,250
2
2 Bed
$3,295
2
2 Bed
$3,075
1
1 Bed
$2,475
975+ sq. ft.
1
1 Bed
$2,500
975+ sq. ft.
1
1 Bed
$2,650
975+ sq. ft.
1
1 Bed
$2,650
975+ sq. ft.
1
1 Bed
$2,770
975+ sq. ft.
1
1 Bed
$2,795
975+ sq. ft.
2
2 Bed
$2,900
1100+ sq. ft.
PetsDogs/Cats
Lease Terms12-Month, 24-Month
NeighborhoodBrookhaven
View All Details
Pet Friendly
$2,220+
Fairfield Greens At Holbrook Apartments
Details
1
1 Bed
$2,230
550+ sq. ft.
1
1 Bed
$2,220
550+ sq. ft.
1
1 Bed
$2,271
625+ sq. ft.
1
1 Bed
$2,271
630+ sq. ft.
1
1 Bed
$2,380
760+ sq. ft.
1
1 Bed
$2,370
765+ sq. ft.
2
2 Bed
$2,960
780+ sq. ft.
2
2 Bed
$2,835
820+ sq. ft.
2
2 Bed
$2,845
840+ sq. ft.
2
2 Bed
$3,190
850+ sq. ft.
2
2 Bed
$3,190
850+ sq. ft.
2
2 Bed
$2,960
854+ sq. ft.
2
2 Bed
$2,950
854+ sq. ft.
2
2 Bed
$2,960
870+ sq. ft.
2
2 Bed
$3,280
970+ sq. ft.
PetsDogs/Cats
Lease Terms12 & 24 month lease terms.
NeighborhoodIslip
View All Details
10+ Units Available
Loading...
Pet Friendly
$2,115+
Fairfield At Selden Apartments
Details
1
1 Bed
$2,115
660+ sq. ft.
1
1 Bed
$2,125
660+ sq. ft.
1
1 Bed
$2,270
705+ sq. ft.
1
1 Bed
$2,280
705+ sq. ft.
2
2 Bed
$2,830
990+ sq. ft.
2
2 Bed
$2,850
999+ sq. ft.
PetsDogs/Cats
Lease Terms12 & 24 month lease terms.
NeighborhoodBrookhaven
View All Details
6 Units Available
Pet Friendly
$1,880+
Fairfield Creekside At Patchogue Village Apartments
Details
S
Studio
$1,880
485+ sq. ft.
S
Studio
$1,895
565+ sq. ft.
1
1 Bed
$2,075
565+ sq. ft.
1
1 Bed
$2,260
720+ sq. ft.
1
1 Bed
$2,285
722+ sq. ft.
1
1 Bed
$2,310
722+ sq. ft.
1
1 Bed
$2,310
805+ sq. ft.
1
1 Bed
$2,050
805+ sq. ft.
1
1 Bed
$2,340
805+ sq. ft.
1
1 Bed
$2,370
890+ sq. ft.
2
2 Bed
$2,820
890+ sq. ft.
2
2 Bed
$2,845
890+ sq. ft.
PetsDogs/Cats
Lease Terms12, 24 month lease terms.
NeighborhoodBrookhaven
View All Details
10+ Units Available
Pet Friendly
$1,625+
Oakview Apartments
Details
S
Studio
394+ sq. ft.
S
Studio
$1,625
436+ sq. ft.
1
1 Bed
$1,835+
584+ sq. ft.
2
2 Bed
$2,255+
769+ sq. ft.
3
3 Bed
1023+ sq. ft.
1
1 Bed
$1,940+
548-584+ sq. ft.
PetsCats
Lease TermsVariable
NeighborhoodBrookhaven
View All Details
6 Units Available
Pet Friendly
$2,490+
Fairfield Meadows Apartments
Details
1
1 Bed
$2,540
566+ sq. ft.
1
1 Bed
$2,490
584+ sq. ft.
1
1 Bed
$2,635
607+ sq. ft.
1
1 Bed
$2,590
628+ sq. ft.
1
1 Bed
$2,540
628+ sq. ft.
1
1 Bed
$3,000
685+ sq. ft.
PetsDogs/Cats
Lease Terms12 & 24 month lease terms.
NeighborhoodBrookhaven
View All Details
Pet Friendly
$2,325+
Renaissance Bay Apartments
Details
1
1 Bed
$2,325
620+ sq. ft.
2
2 Bed
$2,550
800+ sq. ft.
1
1 Bed
$2,420
830+ sq. ft.
1
1 Bed
$2,420
850+ sq. ft.
1
1 Bed
$2,725
900+ sq. ft.
2
2 Bed
$2,910
1050+ sq. ft.
PetsDogs/Cats
Lease Terms12-Month
NeighborhoodBrookhaven
View All Details
3 Units Available
Pet Friendly
$2,320+
Fairfield North At Patchogue Apartments
Details
1
1 Bed
$2,320
850+ sq. ft.
1
1 Bed
$2,320
850+ sq. ft.
2
2 Bed
$2,815
995+ sq. ft.
2
2 Bed
$2,815
995+ sq. ft.
PetsDogs/Cats
Lease Terms12 & 24 month lease terms.
NeighborhoodBrookhaven
View All Details
4 Units Available
$2,085+
Fairfield At East Patchogue Apartments
Details
1
1 Bed
$2,340
999+ sq. ft.
2
2 Bed
$2,835
999+ sq. ft.
2
2 Bed
$2,810
999+ sq. ft.
1
1 Bed
$2,310
999+ sq. ft.
1
1 Bed
$2,095
999+ sq. ft.
1
1 Bed
$2,085
999+ sq. ft.
Lease Terms12-Month, 24-Month
NeighborhoodBrookhaven
View All Details
6 Units Available
Loading...
Pet Friendly
$2,109+
Brookwood At Holbrook Apartments
Details
1
1 Bed
$2,109
650+ sq. ft.
2
2 Bed
$2,614
870+ sq. ft.
PetsDogs/Cats
Lease Terms12-Month
NeighborhoodIslip
View All Details
2 Units Available
Pet Friendly
$2,000+
Fairfield At Port Jefferson Apartments
Details
S
Studio
$2,000
480+ sq. ft.
1
1 Bed
$2,145
495+ sq. ft.
1
1 Bed
$2,435
505+ sq. ft.
1
1 Bed
$2,435
560+ sq. ft.
1
1 Bed
$2,435
560+ sq. ft.
1
1 Bed
$2,435
605+ sq. ft.
2
2 Bed
$2,905
690+ sq. ft.
2
2 Bed
$2,905
740+ sq. ft.
2
2 Bed
$2,905
740+ sq. ft.
3
3 Bed
$3,370
1168+ sq. ft.
PetsCats
Lease Terms12 & 24 month lease terms.
NeighborhoodBrookhaven
View All Details
$2,125+
Fairfield Westlake At Patchogue Apartments
Details
2
2 Bed
$2,640
1
1 Bed
$2,125
790-791+ sq. ft.
PetsDogs/Cats
Lease Terms12 & 24 month lease terms.
NeighborhoodBrookhaven
View All Details
Pet Friendly
$2,160+
Fairfield At Lake Grove Apartments
Details
1
1 Bed
$2,330
460+ sq. ft.
S
Studio
$2,160
462+ sq. ft.
S
Studio
$2,170
462+ sq. ft.
1
1 Bed
$2,400
672+ sq. ft.
1
1 Bed
$2,400
672+ sq. ft.
2
2 Bed
$2,915
952+ sq. ft.
1
1 Bed
$2,400
999+ sq. ft.
PetsDogs
Lease Terms12, 24 month lease terms.
NeighborhoodBrookhaven
View All Details
7 Units Available
Pet Friendly
$2,435+
Fairfield Falls Apartments
Details
1
1 Bed
$2,435
650+ sq. ft.
1
1 Bed
$2,435
657+ sq. ft.
2
2 Bed
$2,895
790+ sq. ft.
2
2 Bed
$2,895
790+ sq. ft.
PetsDogs/Cats
Lease TermsVariable, 12-Month, 24-Month
NeighborhoodBrookhaven
View All Details
4 Units Available
Pet Friendly
$2,215+
Fairfield Gardens At Centereach Apartments
Details
1
1 Bed
$2,215
645+ sq. ft.
1
1 Bed
$2,215
650+ sq. ft.
1
1 Bed
$2,285
680+ sq. ft.
1
1 Bed
$2,285
685+ sq. ft.
2
2 Bed
$2,655
715+ sq. ft.
2
2 Bed
$2,655
720+ sq. ft.
PetsDogs/Cats
Lease Terms12 & 24 month lease terms.
NeighborhoodBrookhaven
View All Details
6 Units Available
Pet Friendly
$2,055+
Fairfield Lakeside At Moriches Apartments
Details
1
1 Bed
$2,190
710+ sq. ft.
1
1 Bed
$2,055
710+ sq. ft.
2
2 Bed
$2,465
800+ sq. ft.
PetsDogs/Cats
Lease Terms12, 24 month lease terms.
NeighborhoodBrookhaven
View All Details
Pet Friendly
$2,150+
Fairfield Gardens At Port Jefferson Apartments
Details
1
1 Bed
$2,150
851+ sq. ft.
1
1 Bed
$2,150
851+ sq. ft.
1
1 Bed
$2,365
939+ sq. ft.
2
2 Bed
$2,785
939+ sq. ft.
1
1 Bed
$2,365
939+ sq. ft.
2
2 Bed
$2,785
939+ sq. ft.
2
2 Bed
$2,905
1268+ sq. ft.
2
2 Bed
$2,905
1268+ sq. ft.
PetsDogs/Cats
Lease Terms12 & 24 month lease terms.
NeighborhoodBrookhaven
View All Details
8 Units Available
$2,405+
Fairfield Hillside At Coram Apartments
Details
1
1 Bed
$2,405
800+ sq. ft.
1
1 Bed
$2,415
815+ sq. ft.
2
2 Bed
$2,630
982+ sq. ft.
2
2 Bed
$2,620
999+ sq. ft.
2
2 Bed
$3,100
999+ sq. ft.
Lease Terms12 & 24 month lease terms.
NeighborhoodBrookhaven
View All Details
5 Units Available
$2,450
1bd 1ba
$2,226
1bd 1ba
$2,500
2bd 1ba 875 sq. ft.
$2,100
1bd 1ba
$2,150
1bd 1ba
Number of Bedrooms
Middle Island House Options
Middle Island
Houses 3D and Video ToursMiddle Island
Houses with Air ConditioningMiddle Island
Houses with Disability AccessMiddle Island
Houses with DishwasherMiddle Island
Houses with ElevatorMiddle Island
Houses with Fire PlaceMiddle Island
Houses with GarageMiddle Island
Houses with Gated AccessMiddle Island
Houses with Patio / BalconyMiddle Island
Houses with Washer / Dryer In UnitPet Friendly Houses for Rent in Middle IslandCheap Houses for Rent in Middle IslandLuxury Houses for Rent in Middle IslandRooms for Rent in Middle Island
Nearby Cities
Nearby Neighborhoods
Looking for more?
Other Properties in New York
15 W 139th St32 Arden St unit 3JMODERN APARTMENTIN FOREST HILLS, LOW FEE!!!Hunter Apartments2395 Bay AveParkstead Watertown At City Center Apartments221 East 22nd StreetWoodlake Apartments196 Willoughby St unit 10N90-2 43rd Ave unit 3HTHE NAUTILUS ApartmentsWoodcreek Village Apartments247-20 89th Ave736 Riverside Dr unit 6-F470 4TH AVENUE Apartments250 S End Ave unit 7T890 W Beech St #1ESV Apartments325 E 92nd St unit 5F334 E 90th St unit 1-2C350 E 65th St unit 15B24 Edgewater Pl #4057093 NY 104103 W 80th St unit 5AWest 52nd Street457 Hamilton St unit 140 Clayton Ave unit 1511 E 35th St unit 2The Selby ApartmentsGreece Commons Apartments
Rentals.com is part of the Rent. Network of Sites
© 2024 Rent Group Inc. All photos, videos, text and other content are the property of Rent Group Inc. RENTALS.COM and the RENTALS.COM Trade Dress are registered trademarks of Rent Group Inc. All rights reserved.
If you are using a screen reader, or are having trouble reading this website, please email accessibilityfeedback@rent.com.