39 Houses For Rent in Bay Shore, NY
Sort: Best Match
$5,500
3bd 2.5ba 1,941 sq. ft.
Special Offer
Pet Friendly
$2,390+
Avalon Amityville Apartments
Details
S
Studio
$2,415
569+ sq. ft.
S
Studio
$2,390+
593+ sq. ft.
S
Studio
611+ sq. ft.
S
Studio
$2,400+
629+ sq. ft.
1
1 Bed
$2,950
703+ sq. ft.
1
1 Bed
$2,940+
705+ sq. ft.
1
1 Bed
$2,970+
719+ sq. ft.
1
1 Bed
$2,975
748+ sq. ft.
1
1 Bed
$2,920
768+ sq. ft.
1
1 Bed
773+ sq. ft.
1
1 Bed
$2,935
784+ sq. ft.
1
1 Bed
$3,030
795+ sq. ft.
1
1 Bed
$2,900
804+ sq. ft.
1
1 Bed
$2,975
817+ sq. ft.
1
1 Bed
$2,995
836+ sq. ft.
1
1 Bed
$2,945
841+ sq. ft.
1
1 Bed
$2,955
853+ sq. ft.
1
1 Bed
862+ sq. ft.
1
1 Bed
867+ sq. ft.
1
1 Bed
877+ sq. ft.
1
1 Bed
884+ sq. ft.
1
1 Bed
895+ sq. ft.
1
1 Bed
906+ sq. ft.
1
1 Bed
951+ sq. ft.
1
1 Bed
$3,585
951+ sq. ft.
1
1 Bed
952+ sq. ft.
1
1 Bed
967+ sq. ft.
1
1 Bed
$3,700
981+ sq. ft.
1
1 Bed
988+ sq. ft.
1
1 Bed
$3,605
1025+ sq. ft.
1
1 Bed
1034+ sq. ft.
1
1 Bed
1038+ sq. ft.
1
1 Bed
1044+ sq. ft.
1
1 Bed
1047+ sq. ft.
2
2 Bed
$3,500+
1062+ sq. ft.
1
1 Bed
1067+ sq. ft.
1
1 Bed
1068+ sq. ft.
1
1 Bed
1083+ sq. ft.
1
1 Bed
1088+ sq. ft.
1
1 Bed
1089+ sq. ft.
1
1 Bed
1093+ sq. ft.
1
1 Bed
1136+ sq. ft.
2
2 Bed
1145+ sq. ft.
1
1 Bed
1149+ sq. ft.
2
2 Bed
1153+ sq. ft.
1
1 Bed
1159+ sq. ft.
2
2 Bed
1165+ sq. ft.
2
2 Bed
1169+ sq. ft.
2
2 Bed
1170+ sq. ft.
1
1 Bed
1173+ sq. ft.
2
2 Bed
$4,045
1243+ sq. ft.
2
2 Bed
$3,940
1266+ sq. ft.
3
3 Bed
1270+ sq. ft.
2
2 Bed
1278+ sq. ft.
2
2 Bed
1284+ sq. ft.
2
2 Bed
1286+ sq. ft.
2
2 Bed
1300+ sq. ft.
2
2 Bed
1314+ sq. ft.
2
2 Bed
$4,135
1331+ sq. ft.
2
2 Bed
$3,890
1332+ sq. ft.
2
2 Bed
$4,120
1336+ sq. ft.
2
2 Bed
1336+ sq. ft.
2
2 Bed
1348+ sq. ft.
2
2 Bed
1352+ sq. ft.
2
2 Bed
$4,145
1353+ sq. ft.
2
2 Bed
1365+ sq. ft.
2
2 Bed
1375+ sq. ft.
2
2 Bed
1378+ sq. ft.
3
3 Bed
1404+ sq. ft.
2
2 Bed
1412+ sq. ft.
2
2 Bed
1473+ sq. ft.
2
2 Bed
$4,120
1474+ sq. ft.
3
3 Bed
1477+ sq. ft.
2
2 Bed
1511+ sq. ft.
2
2 Bed
1519+ sq. ft.
2
2 Bed
1564+ sq. ft.
2
2 Bed
1569+ sq. ft.
2
2 Bed
1588+ sq. ft.
2
2 Bed
1596+ sq. ft.
2
2 Bed
1634+ sq. ft.
2
2 Bed
1759+ sq. ft.
2
2 Bed
1788+ sq. ft.
S
Studio
1859+ sq. ft.
S
Studio
1911+ sq. ft.
S
Studio
1969+ sq. ft.
S
Studio
2139+ sq. ft.
1
1 Bed
795-834+ sq. ft.
1
1 Bed
$2,975+
748-931+ sq. ft.
PetsDogs/Cats
Lease TermsVariable
NeighborhoodBabylon
View All Details
10+ Units Available
Loading...
Special Offer
Pet Friendly
$3,110+
Avalon Huntington Station Apartments
Details
1
1 Bed
713+ sq. ft.
1
1 Bed
$3,140
713+ sq. ft.
1
1 Bed
$3,110
718+ sq. ft.
1
1 Bed
718+ sq. ft.
1
1 Bed
730+ sq. ft.
1
1 Bed
730+ sq. ft.
1
1 Bed
787+ sq. ft.
1
1 Bed
787+ sq. ft.
1
1 Bed
806+ sq. ft.
1
1 Bed
806+ sq. ft.
1
1 Bed
862+ sq. ft.
1
1 Bed
$3,445
875+ sq. ft.
1
1 Bed
897+ sq. ft.
1
1 Bed
897+ sq. ft.
1
1 Bed
$3,480
964+ sq. ft.
1
1 Bed
967+ sq. ft.
1
1 Bed
$3,411
998+ sq. ft.
2
2 Bed
$3,430+
1048+ sq. ft.
2
2 Bed
1048+ sq. ft.
2
2 Bed
1074+ sq. ft.
2
2 Bed
$3,601
1074+ sq. ft.
1
1 Bed
1074+ sq. ft.
2
2 Bed
1074+ sq. ft.
2
2 Bed
$3,607+
1090+ sq. ft.
2
2 Bed
1090+ sq. ft.
2
2 Bed
$3,720+
1127+ sq. ft.
2
2 Bed
1127+ sq. ft.
2
2 Bed
1127+ sq. ft.
2
2 Bed
1127+ sq. ft.
2
2 Bed
$3,440
1181+ sq. ft.
2
2 Bed
1181+ sq. ft.
1
1 Bed
$3,785
1191+ sq. ft.
2
2 Bed
$3,883
1217+ sq. ft.
2
2 Bed
1221+ sq. ft.
2
2 Bed
1221+ sq. ft.
2
2 Bed
1242+ sq. ft.
1
1 Bed
1244+ sq. ft.
2
2 Bed
$3,907
1245+ sq. ft.
3
3 Bed
1248+ sq. ft.
2
2 Bed
1253+ sq. ft.
3
3 Bed
1256+ sq. ft.
3
3 Bed
$3,995+
1256+ sq. ft.
2
2 Bed
1258+ sq. ft.
1
1 Bed
1278+ sq. ft.
2
2 Bed
1293+ sq. ft.
2
2 Bed
1301+ sq. ft.
3
3 Bed
$4,349
1381+ sq. ft.
3
3 Bed
1381+ sq. ft.
2
2 Bed
1389+ sq. ft.
2
2 Bed
$4,107
1437+ sq. ft.
3
3 Bed
1474+ sq. ft.
3
3 Bed
$4,467+
1487+ sq. ft.
3
3 Bed
1543+ sq. ft.
3
3 Bed
1543+ sq. ft.
2
2 Bed
1574+ sq. ft.
3
3 Bed
1586+ sq. ft.
3
3 Bed
1586+ sq. ft.
3
3 Bed
1652+ sq. ft.
3
3 Bed
1841+ sq. ft.
3
3 Bed
1700-1704+ sq. ft.
2
2 Bed
1574-1578+ sq. ft.
2
2 Bed
1217-1235+ sq. ft.
1
1 Bed
944-949+ sq. ft.
PetsDogs/Cats
View All Details
10+ Units Available
Special Offer
Pet Friendly
$3,585+
Avalon Garden City Apartments
Details
1
1 Bed
786+ sq. ft.
1
1 Bed
898+ sq. ft.
1
1 Bed
$3,585
901+ sq. ft.
2
2 Bed
$4,225
1032+ sq. ft.
2
2 Bed
1114+ sq. ft.
2
2 Bed
$4,330+
1116+ sq. ft.
2
2 Bed
$4,400
1249+ sq. ft.
2
2 Bed
$4,555+
1300+ sq. ft.
2
2 Bed
1361+ sq. ft.
2
2 Bed
$4,747
1378+ sq. ft.
2
2 Bed
1429+ sq. ft.
3
3 Bed
$5,920+
1885+ sq. ft.
2
2 Bed
$5,162
1930+ sq. ft.
2
2 Bed
$5,260
1930+ sq. ft.
3
3 Bed
$6,095
2118+ sq. ft.
1
1 Bed
1035-1042+ sq. ft.
PetsDogs/Cats
Lease TermsVariable
NeighborhoodHempstead
View All Details
10+ Units Available
Pet Friendly
$2,770+
Fairfield Townhouses At Babylon Village Apartments
Details
1
1 Bed
$2,770
600+ sq. ft.
2
2 Bed
$3,480
1800+ sq. ft.
PetsDogs/Cats
Lease Terms12 & 24 month lease terms.
NeighborhoodBabylon
View All Details
Pet Friendly
$2,825+
Fairfield The Wel At Lindenhurst Apartments
Details
S
Studio
599+ sq. ft.
S
Studio
694+ sq. ft.
1
1 Bed
$3,000
707+ sq. ft.
S
Studio
723+ sq. ft.
1
1 Bed
$2,895
726+ sq. ft.
1
1 Bed
732+ sq. ft.
1
1 Bed
738+ sq. ft.
1
1 Bed
749+ sq. ft.
1
1 Bed
$2,950+
750+ sq. ft.
1
1 Bed
753+ sq. ft.
1
1 Bed
757+ sq. ft.
1
1 Bed
759+ sq. ft.
1
1 Bed
$2,825
765+ sq. ft.
1
1 Bed
798+ sq. ft.
1
1 Bed
886+ sq. ft.
1
1 Bed
889+ sq. ft.
1
1 Bed
950+ sq. ft.
1
1 Bed
952+ sq. ft.
1
1 Bed
981+ sq. ft.
1
1 Bed
995+ sq. ft.
1
1 Bed
1046+ sq. ft.
2
2 Bed
1063+ sq. ft.
2
2 Bed
1093+ sq. ft.
2
2 Bed
1093+ sq. ft.
2
2 Bed
$4,095
1117+ sq. ft.
2
2 Bed
$3,750
1117+ sq. ft.
2
2 Bed
1123+ sq. ft.
2
2 Bed
1129+ sq. ft.
2
2 Bed
1143+ sq. ft.
2
2 Bed
1149+ sq. ft.
2
2 Bed
1150+ sq. ft.
1
1 Bed
1206+ sq. ft.
1
1 Bed
$3,750
1214+ sq. ft.
1
1 Bed
1224+ sq. ft.
2
2 Bed
1236+ sq. ft.
3
3 Bed
1402+ sq. ft.
3
3 Bed
1528+ sq. ft.
3
3 Bed
1612+ sq. ft.
3
3 Bed
1832+ sq. ft.
PetsDogs/Cats
Lease TermsVariable
NeighborhoodBabylon
View All Details
2 Units Available
Pet Friendly
Furnished
$3,085+
Fairfield Knolls North At Port Jefferson Apartments
Details
2
2 Bed
$3,760
1299+ sq. ft.
2
2 Bed
$3,610
1299+ sq. ft.
2
2 Bed
$3,915
1315+ sq. ft.
2
2 Bed
$3,585
1315+ sq. ft.
2
2 Bed
$3,865
1340+ sq. ft.
2
2 Bed
$3,610
1340+ sq. ft.
2
2 Bed
$3,265
1376+ sq. ft.
2
2 Bed
$3,910
1381+ sq. ft.
2
2 Bed
$3,710
1381+ sq. ft.
2
2 Bed
$3,910
1446+ sq. ft.
2
2 Bed
$3,730
1446+ sq. ft.
2
2 Bed
$3,830
1466+ sq. ft.
2
2 Bed
$3,730
1466+ sq. ft.
2
2 Bed
$3,430
1466+ sq. ft.
2
2 Bed
$3,475
1466+ sq. ft.
2
2 Bed
$3,425
1479+ sq. ft.
2
2 Bed
$3,885
1481+ sq. ft.
2
2 Bed
$3,530
1481+ sq. ft.
2
2 Bed
$3,090
1511+ sq. ft.
2
2 Bed
$3,085
1511+ sq. ft.
2
2 Bed
$3,970
1597+ sq. ft.
2
2 Bed
$3,745
1597+ sq. ft.
2
2 Bed
$4,015
1597+ sq. ft.
2
2 Bed
$3,415
1656+ sq. ft.
2
2 Bed
$3,210
1750+ sq. ft.
2
2 Bed
$3,185
1750+ sq. ft.
2
2 Bed
$3,250
1750+ sq. ft.
2
2 Bed
$3,265
1750+ sq. ft.
2
2 Bed
$3,970
1958+ sq. ft.
2
2 Bed
$3,670
1958+ sq. ft.
PetsDogs/Cats
Lease TermsLease term: 12 month or 24 month leases.
NeighborhoodBrookhaven
View All Details
Pet Friendly
$2,735+
Fairfield Knolls South Apartments
Details
2
2 Bed
$3,315
999+ sq. ft.
2
2 Bed
$2,975
1311+ sq. ft.
2
2 Bed
$2,795
1341+ sq. ft.
2
2 Bed
$3,170
1346+ sq. ft.
2
2 Bed
$3,370
1346+ sq. ft.
2
2 Bed
$3,470
1346+ sq. ft.
2
2 Bed
$2,880
1385+ sq. ft.
2
2 Bed
$3,415
1400+ sq. ft.
2
2 Bed
$3,470
1417+ sq. ft.
2
2 Bed
$3,370
1417+ sq. ft.
2
2 Bed
$3,040
1479+ sq. ft.
2
2 Bed
$3,315
1479+ sq. ft.
2
2 Bed
$3,355
1479+ sq. ft.
2
2 Bed
$3,140
1481+ sq. ft.
2
2 Bed
$3,380
1508+ sq. ft.
2
2 Bed
$3,495
1508+ sq. ft.
2
2 Bed
$3,495
1508+ sq. ft.
2
2 Bed
$2,735
1523+ sq. ft.
2
2 Bed
$3,645
1610+ sq. ft.
2
2 Bed
$3,370
1610+ sq. ft.
2
2 Bed
$3,545
1610+ sq. ft.
2
2 Bed
$3,080
1656+ sq. ft.
2
2 Bed
$3,305
1728+ sq. ft.
2
2 Bed
$2,835
1762+ sq. ft.
2
2 Bed
$2,860
1765+ sq. ft.
2
2 Bed
$3,395
2207+ sq. ft.
PetsDogs/Cats
Lease Terms12, 24 month lease terms.
NeighborhoodBrookhaven
View All Details
Pet Friendly
$3,399+
The Selby Apartments
Details
S
Studio
$4,850
510+ sq. ft.
S
Studio
$3,399
510+ sq. ft.
1
1 Bed
$4,038
979+ sq. ft.
1
1 Bed
$4,650
979+ sq. ft.
1
1 Bed
$4,550
1019+ sq. ft.
1
1 Bed
$4,799
1019+ sq. ft.
1
1 Bed
$4,650
1047+ sq. ft.
1
1 Bed
$5,395
1167+ sq. ft.
1
1 Bed
$5,375
1167+ sq. ft.
1
1 Bed
$5,250
1174+ sq. ft.
1
1 Bed
$5,250
1174+ sq. ft.
1
1 Bed
$5,299
1187+ sq. ft.
1
1 Bed
$5,300
1262+ sq. ft.
2
2 Bed
$5,910
1340+ sq. ft.
2
2 Bed
$6,450
1361+ sq. ft.
2
2 Bed
$5,895
1361+ sq. ft.
2
2 Bed
$6,600
1371+ sq. ft.
2
2 Bed
$6,700+
1371+ sq. ft.
2
2 Bed
$6,800
1380+ sq. ft.
2
2 Bed
$6,700+
1380+ sq. ft.
2
2 Bed
$6,365
1385+ sq. ft.
2
2 Bed
$6,300
1385+ sq. ft.
2
2 Bed
$6,100
1503+ sq. ft.
2
2 Bed
$6,875+
1519+ sq. ft.
2
2 Bed
$7,250
1643+ sq. ft.
2
2 Bed
$7,750
1718+ sq. ft.
3
3 Bed
$10,000
2121+ sq. ft.
3
3 Bed
$10,000
2129+ sq. ft.
3
3 Bed
$7,700
2220+ sq. ft.
3
3 Bed
$7,900
2220+ sq. ft.
3
3 Bed
$8,200
2220+ sq. ft.
3
3 Bed
$7,750
1818-1718+ sq. ft.
PetsDogs/Cats
Lease TermsVariable
NeighborhoodHempstead
View All Details
5 Units Available
Loading...
$4,300
4bd 2ba 1,900 sq. ft.
$8,000
5bd 3.5ba 2,389 sq. ft.
$4,500
2bd 2.5ba 2,000 sq. ft.
$18,000
5bd 4ba 4,000 sq. ft.
$5,270
5bd 2.5ba 2,300 sq. ft.
$20,000
3bd 2.5ba 2,200 sq. ft.
$30,000
4bd 2.5ba 2,766 sq. ft.
Loading...
$11,500
4bd 3.5ba 4,249 sq. ft.
$15,000
5bd 5.5ba 6,000 sq. ft.
$5,900
4bd 2.5ba 2,480 sq. ft.
$90,000
6bd 6.5ba 10,816 sq. ft.
$4,500
4bd 2.5ba 2,160 sq. ft.
$5,000
4bd 2ba 1,856 sq. ft.
$4,000
3bd 2ba 8,712 sq. ft.
$4,000
4bd 2ba 1,872 sq. ft.
$13,000
5bd 3.5ba 5,000 sq. ft.
$4,800
3bd 1.5ba 2,500 sq. ft.
$2,800
2bd 1ba 1,851 sq. ft.
$7,200
7bd 3ba 2,500 sq. ft.
$35,000
7bd 6.5ba 6,621 sq. ft.
$5,500
4bd 2.5ba 2,800 sq. ft.
Number of Bedrooms
Bay Shore House Options
Bay Shore
Houses 3D and Video ToursBay Shore
Houses with Air ConditioningBay Shore
Houses with Disability AccessBay Shore
Houses with DishwasherBay Shore
Houses with ElevatorBay Shore
Houses with Fire PlaceFurnished Houses
in
Bay ShoreBay Shore
Houses with GarageBay Shore
Houses with Gated AccessBay Shore
Houses with Patio / BalconyBay Shore
Houses with Senior LivingBay Shore
Houses with Washer / Dryer ConnectionsBay Shore
Houses with Washer / Dryer In UnitPet Friendly Houses for Rent in Bay ShoreCheap Houses for Rent in Bay ShoreLuxury Houses for Rent in Bay ShoreRooms for Rent in Bay Shore
Nearby Cities
Ocean Beach, NYBay Shore, NYHuntington, NYFreeport, NYWest Babylon, NYCopiague, NYPort Jefferson Station, NYFarmingdale, NYPatchogue, NYPoint Lookout, NYSayville, NYOyster Bay, NYBabylon, NYBellport, NYCoram, NYAmityville, NYHuntington Station, NYMassapequa, NYLindenhurst, NYWestbury, NYCentral Islip, NYMiddle Island, NYNorthport, NYCentereach, NYIslip, NYStony Brook, NYDeer Park, NYHempstead, NYPlainview, NYSmithtown, NYSyosset, NYBaldwin, NYBrentwood, NYEast Islip, NYEast Meadow, NYHauppauge, NYRonkonkoma, NYBayport, NYBethpage, NYFarmingville, NYJericho, NYLevittown, NYNorth Babylon, NYPort Jefferson, NYUniondale, NYCommack, NYEast Northport, NYEast Patchogue, NYGlen Head, NYGreenlawn, NYHicksville, NYHolbrook, NYIslip Terrace, NYKings Park, NYLake Grove, NYWest Islip, NYBellmore, NYBohemia, NYCenterport, NYGarden City, NYMedford, NYMelville, NYMerrick, NYNesconset, NYOakdale, NYSeaford, NYSelden, NYWantagh, NYWest Sayville, NYWoodbury, NYWyandanch, NY
Nearby Neighborhoods
Looking for more?
Other Properties in New York
202 Linden Ave unit 20115 Avenue A unit 5Donald E. Smith Apartments17 Battery Pl unit 2009302 W Creek Ln955 Pacific St102-110 N Main St #1066645 Broadway unit 5CThe Oaks Independent Senior Living Apartments95 Wall St unit 01-1415160 Riverside Blvd unit 6VMixed-Use Development Apartments70 W 37th St unit 1907Smith Woodward Plaza ApartmentsMODERN APARTMENTIN FOREST HILLS, LOW FEE!!!2961 Marion Ave89 Lisbon Ave #LOWER540 Northend Dr unit 3102Parkstead Watertown At Black River Apartments122 Remsen StMt Carmel Apartments338 E 100th St unit 1B3 Harvest Ridge TrThe Meadows Apartments95 E 7th St45 E 95th St1609 St Paul St430 W 34th St.335 Surf RdBrambury Ridge Apartments
Rentals.com is part of the Rent. Network of Sites
© 2024 Rent Group Inc. All photos, videos, text and other content are the property of Rent Group Inc. RENTALS.COM and the RENTALS.COM Trade Dress are registered trademarks of Rent Group Inc. All rights reserved.
If you are using a screen reader, or are having trouble reading this website, please email accessibilityfeedback@rent.com.